Skip to content

Captain's Choice

Artisan Aftershave, Shaving Soaps, Shaving Creams, and Shaving Accessories, made in the USA.  One of the best bay rum aftershaves on the market!
  • Original price $21.95 - Original price $21.95
    Original price
    $21.95
    $21.95 - $21.95
    Current price $21.95

    Captain's Choice 45th Parallel Artisan Aftershave Splash, 4oz

    Captain's Choice

    Whoever said that an aftershave can’t smell simply luscious? The predominant cherry scent with a hint of almond makes this aftershave a unique offe...

    View full details
    Original price $21.95 - Original price $21.95
    Original price
    $21.95
    $21.95 - $21.95
    Current price $21.95
  • Original price $17.95 - Original price $17.95
    Original price
    $17.95
    $17.95 - $17.95
    Current price $17.95

    Captain's Choice 45th Parallel Artisan Shaving Cream, 4oz

    Captain's Choice

    45th Parallel: A heavenly fusion of fragrances, including almond and cherry, for a blissful shave every time.  Spanning the globe, the 45th Paralle...

    View full details
    Original price $17.95 - Original price $17.95
    Original price
    $17.95
    $17.95 - $17.95
    Current price $17.95
  • Original price $20.95 - Original price $20.95
    Original price
    $20.95
    $20.95 - $20.95
    Current price $20.95

    Captain's Choice 45th Parallel Artisan Shaving Soap, 5oz

    Captain's Choice 3 reviews

    Bursting with good cheer, 45th Parallel will put a smile on your face the moment you first inhale its tantalizing aroma. Infused with a blend of es...

    View full details
    Original price $20.95 - Original price $20.95
    Original price
    $20.95
    $20.95 - $20.95
    Current price $20.95
  • Original price $21.95 - Original price $21.95
    Original price
    $21.95
    $21.95 - $21.95
    Current price $21.95

    Captain's Choice Bay Rum Artisan Aftershave Splash, 4oz

    Captain's Choice 13 reviews

    Captain's Choice Original has a natural deep amber color and is presented in a classic amber bottle. The wonderful bay scent predominates with subt...

    View full details
    Original price $21.95 - Original price $21.95
    Original price
    $21.95
    $21.95 - $21.95
    Current price $21.95
  • Original price $17.95 - Original price $17.95
    Original price
    $17.95
    $17.95 - $17.95
    Current price $17.95

    Captain's Choice Bay Rum Artisan Shaving Cream, 4oz

    Captain's Choice 2 reviews

    Bay Rum: A top-notch performer with a marvelous bay scent and traces of cinnamon and citrus. Savor the aromatic blend of a heady bay scent mixed wi...

    View full details
    Original price $17.95 - Original price $17.95
    Original price
    $17.95
    $17.95 - $17.95
    Current price $17.95
  • Original price $20.95 - Original price $20.95
    Original price
    $20.95
    $20.95 - $20.95
    Current price $20.95

    Captain's Choice Bay Rum Artisan Shaving Soap, 5oz

    Captain's Choice 8 reviews

    Scented with the same proprietary concentrate used in our Bay Rum aftershave, we now present a matching shaving soap! Luxuriate in the thick creamy...

    View full details
    Original price $20.95 - Original price $20.95
    Original price
    $20.95
    $20.95 - $20.95
    Current price $20.95
  • Original price $21.95 - Original price $21.95
    Original price
    $21.95
    $21.95 - $21.95
    Current price $21.95

    Captain's Choice Cat O' Nine Tails Artisan Aftershave Splash, 4oz

    Captain's Choice 11 reviews

    Created to answer the need for a more bracing experience, Cat O' Nine Tails delivers!   It may be in the bay rum family, but look out - it has a LO...

    View full details
    Original price $21.95 - Original price $21.95
    Original price
    $21.95
    $21.95 - $21.95
    Current price $21.95
    Sold out
  • Original price $21.95 - Original price $21.95
    Original price
    $21.95
    $21.95 - $21.95
    Current price $21.95

    Captain's Choice Eucalyptus Artisan Aftershave Splash, 4oz

    Captain's Choice

    Native to southeastern Australia, Eucalyptus is unique for its camphor-like and lemony notes. Blended with just a dash of spearmint, a truly uplift...

    View full details
    Original price $21.95 - Original price $21.95
    Original price
    $21.95
    $21.95 - $21.95
    Current price $21.95
  • Original price $20.95 - Original price $20.95
    Original price
    $20.95
    $20.95 - $20.95
    Current price $20.95

    Captain's Choice Eucalyptus Artisan Shaving Soap, 5oz

    Captain's Choice

    Eucalyptus - If an exhilarating scent is what you are after, this is the one! The dash of spearmint added to what is already a naturally invigorati...

    View full details
    Original price $20.95 - Original price $20.95
    Original price
    $20.95
    $20.95 - $20.95
    Current price $20.95
  • Original price $49.95 - Original price $49.95
    Original price
    $49.95
    $49.95 - $49.95
    Current price $49.95

    Captain's Choice Heavyweight Handmade Copper Lather Bowl, Flared Edge

    Captain's Choice 2 reviews

    Finally, an unbreakable lather bowl with that vintage look! Constructed with a thicker gauge copper than the Standard copper lather bowl, the Heavy...

    View full details
    Original price $49.95 - Original price $49.95
    Original price
    $49.95
    $49.95 - $49.95
    Current price $49.95
  • Original price $21.95 - Original price $21.95
    Original price
    $21.95
    $21.95 - $21.95
    Current price $21.95

    Captain's Choice Italia Artisan Aftershave Splash, 4oz

    Captain's Choice 2 Reviews

    The oh-so-intoxicating aroma found in traditional Italian barber shops - welcome to the world of Italia. Breathe deep and experience the warmth of ...

    View full details
    Original price $21.95 - Original price $21.95
    Original price
    $21.95
    $21.95 - $21.95
    Current price $21.95
  • Original price $20.95 - Original price $20.95
    Original price
    $20.95
    $20.95 - $20.95
    Current price $20.95

    Captain's Choice Italia Artisan Shaving Soap, 5oz

    Captain's Choice

    The timeless almond scent of the Old World can be yours. Experience a bit of Old World Italia with this delightful almond scent!  The warmth of thi...

    View full details
    Original price $20.95 - Original price $20.95
    Original price
    $20.95
    $20.95 - $20.95
    Current price $20.95
  • Original price $39.95 - Original price $39.95
    Original price
    $39.95
    $39.95 - $39.95
    Current price $39.95

    Captain's Choice Lather Bowl Gunmetal Finish Handmade Ceramic

    Captain's Choice 2 reviews

    These bowls are not available for international shipping due to high chance of breaking. GUNMETAL - versatile and always in style, this high-gloss ...

    View full details
    Original price $39.95 - Original price $39.95
    Original price
    $39.95
    $39.95 - $39.95
    Current price $39.95
    Sold out
  • Original price $21.95 - Original price $21.95
    Original price
    $21.95
    $21.95 - $21.95
    Current price $21.95

    Captain's Choice Lime Artisan Aftershave Splash, 4oz

    Captain's Choice 17 reviews

    Captain’s Choice has brought to market a genuine lime aftershave that is in a class unto itself! Now you can look forward to the cheerful aroma of ...

    View full details
    Original price $21.95 - Original price $21.95
    Original price
    $21.95
    $21.95 - $21.95
    Current price $21.95
  • Original price $17.95 - Original price $17.95
    Original price
    $17.95
    $17.95 - $17.95
    Current price $17.95

    Captain's Choice Lime Artisan Shaving Cream, 4oz

    Captain's Choice

    Lime: An invigorating, citrusy scent for a morning energy boost.A cheerful, refreshing lime scent greets you with this selection from Captain’s Cho...

    View full details
    Original price $17.95 - Original price $17.95
    Original price
    $17.95
    $17.95 - $17.95
    Current price $17.95
  • Original price $20.95 - Original price $20.95
    Original price
    $20.95
    $20.95 - $20.95
    Current price $20.95

    Captain's Choice Lime Artisan Shaving Soap, 5oz

    Captain's Choice 1 review

    Scented with the same proprietary concentrate used in our Lime aftershave, we now present a matching shaving soap! Luxuriate in the thick creamy la...

    View full details
    Original price $20.95 - Original price $20.95
    Original price
    $20.95
    $20.95 - $20.95
    Current price $20.95
  • Original price $21.95 - Original price $21.95
    Original price
    $21.95
    $21.95 - $21.95
    Current price $21.95

    Captain's Choice Nor'easter Artisan Aftershave Splash, 4oz

    Captain's Choice 2 reviews

    A refreshing menthol that will become a favorite. Proudly handcrafted in America. Originating in the North Atlantic, Nor’easters thrive and pick up...

    View full details
    Original price $21.95 - Original price $21.95
    Original price
    $21.95
    $21.95 - $21.95
    Current price $21.95
  • Original price $17.95 - Original price $17.95
    Original price
    $17.95
    $17.95 - $17.95
    Current price $17.95

    Captain's Choice Nor'easter Artisan Shaving Cream, 4oz

    Captain's Choice

    Lather up with this refreshing menthol for a breath of fresh air! Originating in the North Atlantic, Nor’easters thrive and pick up strength from t...

    View full details
    Original price $17.95 - Original price $17.95
    Original price
    $17.95
    $17.95 - $17.95
    Current price $17.95
  • Original price $20.95 - Original price $20.95
    Original price
    $20.95
    $20.95 - $20.95
    Current price $20.95

    Captain's Choice Nor'easter Artisan Shaving Soap with Menthol, 5oz

    Captain's Choice 1 review

    Inhale that invigorating menthol scent for a mind-clearing experience! Originating in the North Atlantic, Nor’easters thrive and pick up strength f...

    View full details
    Original price $20.95 - Original price $20.95
    Original price
    $20.95
    $20.95 - $20.95
    Current price $20.95
  • Original price $21.95 - Original price $21.95
    Original price
    $21.95
    $21.95 - $21.95
    Current price $21.95

    Captain's Choice North Artisan Aftershave Spalsh, 4oz

    Captain's Choice 1 review

    Breathe in the invigorating aroma of juniper amid a proprietary blend of other essential oils. No need to go there in person; the North Woods has c...

    View full details
    Original price $21.95 - Original price $21.95
    Original price
    $21.95
    $21.95 - $21.95
    Current price $21.95
  • Original price $21.95 - Original price $21.95
    Original price
    $21.95
    $21.95 - $21.95
    Current price $21.95

    Captain's Choice Sandalwood Artisan Aftershave Splash, 4oz

    Captain's Choice 10 reviews

    Here is a sandalwood aftershave that delivers a modern take on the classic scent. This was developed with the help of dozens of volunteers over the...

    View full details
    Original price $21.95 - Original price $21.95
    Original price
    $21.95
    $21.95 - $21.95
    Current price $21.95
  • Original price $17.95 - Original price $17.95
    Original price
    $17.95
    $17.95 - $17.95
    Current price $17.95

    Captain's Choice Sandalwood Artisan Shaving Cream, 4oz

    Captain's Choice 1 review

    Sandalwood: A gentle, refined scent with a timeless appeal for a superior shave.Imparting a distinctively warm and woody fragrance, the Far East is...

    View full details
    Original price $17.95 - Original price $17.95
    Original price
    $17.95
    $17.95 - $17.95
    Current price $17.95
  • Original price $20.95 - Original price $20.95
    Original price
    $20.95
    $20.95 - $20.95
    Current price $20.95

    Captain's Choice Sandalwood Artisan Shaving Soap, 5oz

    Captain's Choice 3 reviews

    An outstanding performer that serves up a wonderful rich lather every time. Enjoy dependable cushioning and a lather that lasts and lasts and lasts...

    View full details
    Original price $20.95 - Original price $20.95
    Original price
    $20.95
    $20.95 - $20.95
    Current price $20.95
  • Original price $3.20 - Original price $3.75
    Original price
    $3.20 - $3.75
    $3.20 - $3.75
    Current price $3.20

    Captain's Choice Shaving Soap and Aftershave Samples

    Captain's Choice 5 Reviews

    Captain's Choice Products allow for the ideal wet shaving experience each morning. Curate your shave with Captain's Choice Products.  All Captain'...

    View full details
    Original price $3.20 - Original price $3.75
    Original price
    $3.20 - $3.75
    $3.20 - $3.75
    Current price $3.20