Skip to content

Captain's Choice Shaving Soap and Aftershave Samples

2 reviews
Original price $3.20 - Original price $3.75
Original price
$3.20 - $3.75
Current price $3.75

Captain's Choice Products allow for the ideal wet shaving experience each morning. Curate your shave with Captain's Choice Products. 

All Captain's Choice products are proudly made in the United States. With scents as timeless as Bay Rum to adventurous as Cat O' Nine Tails to as fresh as Lime to many more, Captain's Choice Products make each shave the greatest.


  • 45th Parallel - Almond and cherry, for a blissful shave every time.
  • Bay Rum - Bay scent and traces of vanilla, cinnamon and citrus.
  • Cat O'Nine TailsIt may be in the bay rum family, but look out - it has a LOT of personality!  One customer described the scent was, "deeper, darker and somehow more mysterious - the evil twin of bay rum aftershave." Another described the scent as having, “a good manly smell to it, spicy deep and really dark.”
  • Italia - The Old World and allure of almond delivered right to your doorstep.
  • Lime - Refreshing and authentically infused with the produce of Mexico.
  • Nor'Easter - A masculine scent that delivers a bracing menthol effect!
  • Sandalwood - Our twist on the classic men’s fragrance — one for the ages.
  • Venture - A distinctive and inspiring aroma fit for a man of adventure.

Each sample is hand prepared by one of the Maggard Razors team from fresh shave cream/soap tubs and bottles of aftershave splash.
Each soap sample is enough for approximately 5 shaves!
The 1/4oz jars will be filled to the bottom of the threads.

    Aftershaves are packaged in a 12ml spray bottle. International shipping restrictions will apply.

    *SHIPPING RESTRICTIONS: The Aftershaves contain alcohol, which is potentially hazardous for shipping. We can not ship it outside of the continental USA. If you are an international customer, this item will be refunded and will not be shipped.

    • Shipping
    • Returns
    Customer Reviews
    3.5 Based on 2 Reviews
    5 ?
    4 ?
    3 ?
    2 ?
    1 ?
    Write a Review

    Thank you for submitting a review!

    Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

    Filter Reviews:
    Customer review

    I had to opposite experience as the other reviewer. The smell made a Bay Rum lover out of me and the lather was extremely cushioned and slick. I've used many different brands of creams and soaps and this beats out others that are 3 times the price.

    Louis M.
    Customer review

    I got the Bay Rum scent. The scent is incredible. The full size tub is $18 for 5 oz. The lather, unfortunately, disappears. Not fast enough for it to be useless, but fast, nonetheless. This is really a bargain basement soap producing a sub par experience. If you want to smell Bay Rum or smell like Bay Rum, go for some cologne and skip the soap, entirely. Still, if you do buy a sample, at $2.50 you aren't out too much money.