When you click on sort by popularity on the menu at the top with all the Stirling soaps, this Executive Man is their second most popular scent in a line with 83 different choices. I had no idea it was possible to come up with 83 different variations. It is obviously a showcase of the mixologists ability to mix different colognes and while that may be interesting, I don't think I have enough money to become a fan of this company and start collecting them or even to buy several.
I've never tried Creed's GIT, but that was part of the reason I bought this one. At $13.60 for 5.8 oz., it is a bargain soap. $2.34 per oz. I think we feel the ingredients on our face and Cella sure feels better on my face. The lather is slick, but it doesn't seem all that protective. I wouldn't rate it too low. For the price, the product does work and it seems like a good value to me. I just know that if I spend several dollars more and get a few ounces less product, that I can get something I'll be happy with for 6 weeks or however long the container will last me. I applaud the effort the guy made in creating this soap and his company. I spend a lot of money on this hobby and I presume you do, too. It doesn't make sense to cheap out on the soap, when it won't take a lot more money to get something you'll really enjoy and most people are buying way more soaps than they really need, anyway.
I think if you buy Cella or Haslinger or A&E, you will feel a huge difference. You don't have to spend a fortune on Castle Forbes or Abbate y la Mantia in order to go a step up.