Skip to content

Captain's Choice Bay Rum Artisan Shaving Soap, 5oz

8 reviews
We currently have 6 in stock.

Scented with the same proprietary concentrate used in our Bay Rum aftershave, we now present a matching shaving soap! Luxuriate in the thick creamy lather that makes each shave one to remember. We designed the scent to be just "there" and never too prominent for an enjoyable shave each time.

For your convenience, we chose to put the five ounces of soap into an oversize eight-ounce tub. Why, you ask? Ah, to make sure that none of that luscious lather escapes over the sides when loading your brush. During development over thirty volunteers just raved about the results that this soap brought to their morning routine. Now you can join the chorus!

Ingredients: Sodium Coco-Sulfate, Sodium Stearate, Cocomide MEA, Stearic Acid, Water (Aqua), Cetyl Alcohol, Mineral Oil, Fragrance, Isostearamidopropyl Morpholine Lactate, Triethanolamine.


  • Shipping
  • Returns
  • Maggard Razors will make every effort to ship out orders on the same day placed before 12pm EST Monday-Friday. On Saturday, most parcels should ship if placed before 10am EST - otherwise it will ship the following Monday.  Orders will be shipped in the order in which they are received. If it is an unusually busy day your order may be delayed no more than 1 business day. 

  • Unused items (except samples) may be returned within 10 days for a full refund or store credit. For orders that qualified for free or reduced shipping, if a return causes the resulting total order size to be under the free shipping threshold (currently $59.00), the actual cost of shipping we paid will be reduced from your refund. Used products may not be returned, and all sales are final on Samples.

Customer Reviews
4.1 Based on 8 Reviews
5 ?
4 ?
3 ?
2 ?
1 ?
Write a Review

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
Luis G.
Customer review

The ingredients aren't the ones that are displayed. Recived the parcel today (October 2020) and the label says it has mineral oil and other harmful products... I'm really angry.

Customer review

One of the best bay rum , easy lather , good protection on the skin and good scent.

Customer review

great shave soap and i love the smell. i also have the 45th parallel and north scents. each is great in it's own way. i love that you can lather or load up your brush in the container without it foaming up and running down the sides of it. keeps things nice and neat when shaving instead of making a mess everywhere. :)

Customer review

I know scent is a very personal thing, but I did not like the scent of this at all. (For what it's worth, my wife and son both also turned their noses up at it.) It smells very plastic-y to all 3 of us, and not much like what we think of when we think Bay Rum. That said, it is pretty slick and lathers up well enough. My face feels pretty smooth and soft afterwards, so it does the job nicely, but I don't think I'm going to be able to get past the smell. To each their own of course, and I'm glad that the people that like it do like it because I like this company.

Customer review

great slickness and alowes for easy blade glide. the sent is on the milder side of bay rum but is the same as the after shave. it latherd with little to no effort and was enough for a three pass shave. this soap is a softer soap a did not need a water soaking for a bloom. i would recomend this to all that want to try a bay rum shave soap.